This is my old gig
You can try. However, I have a friend who changed her profile picture and when she tried to go back to her original profile picture Fiverr would not let her because they said she had stolen it.
Thank you,for recommendation
I would say you can, but make it somewhat different. Now, will the new Gig be similar to the one you already have? If so, please note that Fiverr won’t allow you to have duplicated Gigs and will remove them.