Okay. I can see one thing you can do. If you go on Fiverr and see the top rated sellers, they have very eye-catching images for their first image on the gig.
When buyers scroll through Fiverr, your gig is one of many they see. Well, what do you do? You have to make your gig pop out. I think that you could replace those images on your gig with more eye catching images that will draw attention to your gig.
The best way to go about doing this is to ask yourself this: "what kind of image would I want to see on a seller’s page that would draw my attention? Make something that will pop and stand out from the others.
Hope this helps.